Sa‘eed bin Musayyib narrates that Hadhrat ‘Umar
once intended to take the house* of Hadhrat ‘Abbas
to include it in the Masjid. However, Hadhrat ‘Abbas
refused to hand the house over. When Hadhrat ‘Umar
resolved that he would certainly have possession of the house, Hadhrat ‘Abbas
proposed that they appoint Hadhrat Ubay bin Ka‘b
to pass judgement between them. Hadhrat ‘Umar
agreed and they both approached Hadhrat Ubay
. After they had related the matter to him, Hadhrat Ubay
said, “Allah sent revelation to Hadhrat Sulayman bin Dawud instructing him to construct Bay al-Maqdis [in Jerusalem]. The land belonged to a man whom Hadhrat Sulayman
approached to buy it from him. However, when Hadhrat Sulayman
handed over the money to the man, he [the man] asked, ‘Is this price that you are paying better or is that which you are taking from me better?’ Hadhrat Sulayman
replied, ‘Certainly that which I am taking from you is better.’ ‘In that case,’ said the man, ‘I shall not accept it.’
Hadhrat Sulayman
then gave the man a higher price. The man then did the same thing two or three times until Hadhrat Sulayman
made the condition with him, ‘I am buying the land from you at the price you fix. You may therefore not ask me which of the two is better.’ Hadhrat Sulayman
took the purchased land from him at the price he fixed, which happened to be twelve thousand Qintar of gold (one Qintar equals four thousand gold coins). Hadhrat Sulayman
then felt that the amount was too big to give the man. Allah then sent revelation to him saying, ‘If you are paying him from something that is your own, then you know best (what you have to do). However, if you are paying from what We have provided for you, then give him whatever he is pleased with.’ Hadhrat Sulayman
then paid the amount.”
Hadhrat Ubay
continued, “I feel that ‘Abbas
has a greater right to his house, which cannot be taken from him until he is pleased.” Hadhrat ‘Abbas
then said, ‘Since you have made the decision in my favour, I wish to make it Sadaqah [a charitable gift] for the Muslims.’
[Hayatus Sahabah (‘The Lives of the Companions’), by Maulana Muhammad Yusuf Kandhelwi, excerpted from the English translation by Mufti Afzal Hoosen Elias, Zam Zam Publishers, Karachi, June 2013, vol. 2, pp. 133-134 (related by Abdur Razzaq, as quoted in Kanzul Ummal vol. 4 p. 260. Also related by Ibn Sa‘d vol. 4 p. 13. Ibn Asakir relates a similar narration, as do Bayhaqi and Ya‘qub bin Sulayman – quoted in Kanzul Ummal vol. 7 p. 65). Words in square brackets have been added.]
*His house was next door to Masjid al-Nabawi